ICT in schools isn’t a magic wand that improves academic performance – Study
Here’s something that may not make immediate sense (especially considering SA’s current drive to get more ICT into schools, not less): having computers and tablets and internet access in schools does not necessarily lead to smarter, better-educated students.
This is according to a new study by PISA, the Programme for International Student Assessment, titled Students, computers and learning: Making the connection.
It’s a 204-page document that goes into substantial detail about the ways in which “…the reality in our schools lags considerably behind the promise of technology”, and how in 2012 there was no appreciable improvement in the reading, maths and science performance of schools in rich countries that had invested heavily in education-focused ICT.
Instead, it’s “intensive teacher-student interactions” and a solid foundation in maths, science and reading skills that are at the heart of a good education, and technology actually serves as a distraction from “this valuable human engagement”.
Great tech can’t replace poor teaching
In short: it’s good teachers, and not good technology, that make for a quality education, and that reading comprehension and a good understanding of maths and science is of greater benefit than access to cutting-edge tech. As the study says, “Technology can amplify great teaching but great technology cannot replace poor teaching”.
Getting more tablets into schools, then, or investing heavily in educational tech isn’t necessarily the way forward for a country interested in producing students who will be ready to take on careers in the information age.
But that’s not all it says. The study also explores the notion that it’s possible modern teaching methods have just not figured out yet how to make the most of technology, and that “adding 21st-century technologies to 20th-century teaching practices will just dilute the effectiveness of teaching.”
So the quest to find the right balance between traditional teaching methodologies and modern-day tech is ongoing, and technology isn’t, of itself, a bad thing to have in schools.
While the study was conducted in first-world OECD countries and reaches back to 2012 for most of its data, it’s relevant for us down here in South Africa as it highlights some pretty important dos and don’ts when it comes to improving our own education system.
The big takeaway is that it’s better teachers and a focus on providing relevant reading, science and maths skills that will ultimately pave the way to having a nation of adults who’re able to cope with – and thrive in – the digital world of the future. And it’s not, quite ironically, better access to computer equipment and the internet that’ll get us there.
If you’d like to read the study in its entirety – and it’s highly recommended if you’re even remotely involved in education in South Africa – you can find it here.[Source – OECD, Image – “OLPC classroom teaching” by RudolfSimon – Own work. Licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0 via Commons.]